AlphaYouAlphaYou vs. Zacks: Live Graded Picks vs. the Zacks Rank
AlphaYou vs Zacks Premium and the Zacks Rank: what each record really measures, what you can check before paying, and which fits you. Checked September 2026.
A ranking of thousands of stocks and a list of picks sound alike. They are not. One tells you how every stock scores today. The other says "this one", then shows you what happened next.
Direct answerZacks Premium ($249 a year) ranks thousands of stocks every day, and says its #1 Rank stocks averaged +23.80% a year against +11.53% for the S&P 500 from 1988 to August 2026, as a hypothetical portfolio. AlphaYou publishes a small set of insider-buy picks, each locked in before its result and graded after 60 days, with every counted pick, losers included, on a free public page.
- Zacks Premium is $249 a year with a 30-day trial. You get the daily Zacks Rank, the full #1 Rank list (the top 5% of stocks), a Focus List of 50 longer-term stocks, research reports and more than 45 screens (checked 24 Sep 2026).
- Accountable. Every pick is a real, dated call, locked in before its result is known and graded 60 days later against the S&P 500 over the same days. Losers stay on the list.
- Zacks wins on history and scale: nearly 40 years of data and a score for almost any stock you look up. If you want a screen-and-rank tool, it is strong.
| Criterion | AlphaYou | Zacks |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A small set of insider-buy picks | A daily ranking of thousands of stocks |
| Kind of record | Each live pick's 60-day result | Hypothetical equal-weighted #1 Rank portfolio |
| Losers visible | Every losing pick, listed | Weak years shown in the yearly table |
| Outside check | Free public page anyone can audit | Accounting examination, 1988 to July 2024 |
| Price | $29 a month or $199 a year, free plan shows 2 live picks | $249 a year, 30-day trial |
| Record starts | May 2026 | 1988 |
What Zacks Gives You
Zacks Premium is $249 a year with a 30-day trial. You get the daily Zacks Rank, the full #1 Rank list (the top 5% of stocks), a Focus List of 50 longer-term stocks, research reports and more than 45 screens (checked 24 Sep 2026).
Credit where it is due: Zacks is more open than most. Its disclosure shows weak years too, such as 2023 (+20.63% against +24.83% for the S&P 500) and 2024 (+22.41% against +28.02%). Accounting firms examined its record from 1988 to July 2024. And Zacks says plainly that its #1 Rank figure is an equal-weighted hypothetical portfolio, before trading costs, that a real account could not have matched.
Why AlphaYou Is Built Differently
Accountable. Every pick is a real, dated call, locked in before its result is known and graded 60 days later against the S&P 500 over the same days. Losers stay on the list.
Provable. Every counted pick is on a free page at alphayou.net/calls/proof, with the price at the next market open and the price 60 days later. It is a live record, not a model.
Built for 2026. Software reads SEC insider filings as they land and checks each stock against up to 7 groups of evidence. A pick goes out when insiders are buying and the rest of the evidence agrees.
It keeps testing itself. Twice a week, a research lab re-tests our scoring against every newly graded pick. A new rule only replaces the current one after it beats the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq-100 on fresh data, over 30, 60 and 90 days.
Where Each One Wins
Zacks wins on history and scale: nearly 40 years of data and a score for almost any stock you look up. If you want a screen-and-rank tool, it is strong.
AlphaYou wins on proof of actual picks. You see each call, when it was made, and how it did, losers included, without paying. Where we are weaker: a record that starts in May 2026 and far fewer stocks covered.
FAQ
Is Zacks Premium worth it?
If you want daily rankings and screens across the market, it is a lot of tool for $249 a year. If you want a short list of picks you can check one by one, look for a service that publishes every pick.
Is the Zacks Rank record real?
It is a hypothetical portfolio, which Zacks states clearly, and accounting firms examined it from 1988 to July 2024.
How is AlphaYou different from Zacks?
AlphaYou publishes a small number of live picks from insider buying and grades each one after 60 days on a free public page.
Which is cheaper?
AlphaYou has a free plan and costs $29 a month or $199 a year. Zacks Premium is $249 a year.
Get the filings this guide is about.
Funds, Congress and insiders, read the moment they file. Free, and one unsubscribe click.