AlphaYouAlphaYou vs. Seeking Alpha: Graded Picks You Can Check vs. a Model Portfolio
AlphaYou vs Seeking Alpha and its Alpha Picks service: how each proves its picks, what you can check before paying, and which fits you. Updated September 2026.
You go to Seeking Alpha for one stock and leave with 12 opinions, a quant score and an offer for Alpha Picks. It is a lot of research. What it does not give you, before you pay, is a list of every pick and how each one did.
Direct answerSeeking Alpha is a large research platform whose pick service, Alpha Picks, sends 2 quant-rated picks a month and reports +358.80% against +104.87% for the S&P 500 from 1 Jul 2022 to 22 Sep 2026, as a model portfolio it says is not audited. The portfolio is for members. AlphaYou grades every insider-buy pick after 60 days and shows every counted pick, losers included, for free.
- A research platform with contributor articles and quant ratings for most US stocks. Its pick service, Alpha Picks, sends 2 picks a month, each with a Strong Buy quant rating held for at least 75 days, plus rules for when to sell. The price appears after sign-in, and review sites list it at $499 a year. The record is a model portfolio: since 31 Jul 2024, picks are entered at the day's average traded price while the S&P 500 fund it is compared with is bought at the open.
- Accountable. Every pick is locked in before its result is known and graded 60 days later against the S&P 500 over the same days. Losers stay on the list, and nothing is re-graded later.
- Seeking Alpha wins on breadth. If you want to read many views on one company and compare quant scores across the market, nothing on this list covers as much ground.
| Criterion | AlphaYou | Seeking Alpha |
|---|---|---|
| Where picks come from | Executives buying their own company's stock, checked against the rest of the evidence | Stocks with a Strong Buy quant rating for 75 or more days |
| How often | When the evidence lines up | 2 a month in Alpha Picks |
| Proof you can check for free | Every counted pick, losers included | A headline model-portfolio return |
| How each pick is graded | 60 days from the next market open, against the S&P 500 over the same days | Model portfolio against SPY bought on each pick date |
| How the rules change | Scoring changes only after beating the S&P 500 and Nasdaq-100 on fresh data | Published buy and sell rules for Alpha Picks |
| Price | $29 a month or $199 a year, free plan shows 2 live picks | Alpha Picks shown after sign-in (review sites: $499 a year) |
| Record starts | May 2026 | July 2022 for Alpha Picks |
What Seeking Alpha Gives You
A research platform with contributor articles and quant ratings for most US stocks. Its pick service, Alpha Picks, sends 2 picks a month, each with a Strong Buy quant rating held for at least 75 days, plus rules for when to sell. The price appears after sign-in, and review sites list it at $499 a year. The record is a model portfolio: since 31 Jul 2024, picks are entered at the day's average traded price while the S&P 500 fund it is compared with is bought at the open.
Why AlphaYou Is Built Differently
Accountable. Every pick is locked in before its result is known and graded 60 days later against the S&P 500 over the same days. Losers stay on the list, and nothing is re-graded later.
Provable. The full record is free at alphayou.net/calls/proof, pick by pick: the price at the next market open, the price 60 days later, and the S&P 500 over the same days. No sign-in needed.
Built for 2026. Software reads SEC insider filings as they land, then checks each stock against up to 7 groups of evidence: the company's numbers, the chart, analysts, news, options and the wider market. A pick goes out when the evidence lines up, not on the 1st and the 15th.
It keeps testing itself. Twice a week, a research lab re-tests our scoring against every newly graded pick. A new scoring rule only replaces the current one after it beats the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq-100 on fresh data, over 30, 60 and 90 days.
Where Each One Wins
Seeking Alpha wins on breadth. If you want to read many views on one company and compare quant scores across the market, nothing on this list covers as much ground.
AlphaYou wins on proof. Every counted pick sits on a free page, losers included, measured the same way, and the scoring keeps being re-tested. Where we are weaker: fewer stocks covered, a record that starts in May 2026, and no contributor articles.
FAQ
Is AlphaYou a Seeking Alpha alternative?
For picks, yes. AlphaYou publishes insider-buy picks with a free, complete record. For broad research articles, Seeking Alpha covers far more.
Are Alpha Picks returns audited?
No. Seeking Alpha describes its method as consistent with industry standards but says it is not an audited, compliant record.
How much does Alpha Picks cost?
Seeking Alpha shows the price after sign-in. Review sites list $499 a year, with $449 offers, as of September 2026.
How is AlphaYou graded?
Each pick is measured from the next market open after it was published to 60 days later, against the S&P 500 over the same days. Every counted pick is public.
Get the filings this guide is about.
Funds, Congress and insiders, read the moment they file. Free, and one unsubscribe click.